This cheating app teaches all the wrong lessons about AI – but some of you still might use it



Cluely, an AI app that promises to help you “cheat at everything,” perhaps deserves some credit for honesty.

If you believe that artificial intelligence is a platform that, in some ways, can help you game the system by delivering melifilous prose written by a large language model (LLM), stunning art generated by ChatGPT, or convincing video percolated by Sora, then maybe Cluely and its founders are just being honest.

It’s more likely, though, that they are blustering their way to the launch of a product that makes a mockery of integrity.

Cluely is a crafty app that installs in your browser and then can sneakily watch and listen to everything on screen. The primary use case is a Zoom video call where you’re being interviewed for a high-paying development job. During such a call, you might be asked to Leetcode, which is essentially solving coding or algorithmic problems in full view of your interviewer. With Cluely running, it could quickly tell you how to respond to questions and even solve the coding problems.

Lee claimed to have used Cluely to breeze through interviews with multiple major tech companies. Word apparently got around to Columbia University, where Lee and his Cluely co-founder were students. Lee was, according to letters he posted on X (formerly Twitter), kicked out. Lee detailed the entire experience in an X thread.

Instead of remorse, Lee seems to express a level of satisfaction, like this is a plan gone well. And, in a way, it is. Cluely has, according to Techcrunch, raised $3.5 million in funding and is prepared to help us “cheat at everything.”

If that statement makes you feel a bit nauseated, you may not be alone. Lee has spent a fair amount of time defending the app on X, and Cluely may not have helped its case with a tongue-in-cheek launch video that depicts the 21-year-old Lee using Cluely in a smartglasses-like app to convince his date that he is 31 and interested in her and her art. She catches on to the subterfuge and ultimately walks out, but the point is made. Cluely could help you cheat at dating.

While Cluely has yet to reveal which LLMs it uses to power its answers, this is a funhouse mirror view of AI’s potential.

In his manifesto (which, it appears, has since disappeared from the site), Lee argues that we need to redefine cheating and that what Cluely’s doing is no different than Google or a calculator, which put answers at our fingertips and perhaps have been helping us “cheat” for decades.

On X, I asked Lee about this perspective, writing:

“Do you worry that your experience teaches the wrong lesson about AI? People are already skeptical, and if they see it as a tool for cheating, maybe some will be less likely to use and engage. At the very least, more people will trust less (on things like job interviews) because they might believe the applicant is using AI to cheat.”

Moments later, Lee responded (For readability, I’ve fixed the punctuation):

“What exactly does “cheat on everything” mean?

How do you ‘cheat’ on a conversation?

Cluely (and AI) enables such an insane amount of leverage that it feels unfair, and “like” cheating.

The world will be uncomfortable with this reality (as you yourself show), but it will soon become normal, and the day that AI maximalism is truly normalized, humanity’s potential will 1,000,000x.

Initial hesitation -> massive adoption has been how every single technology in the history of the world has spread.”

Cheating is…cheating

While I can’t disagree with the notion about hesitation and then mass adoption, and am seeing that in real-time with consumer-grade AI, Lee seems to imply that you can’t “cheat” at a conversation. I guess he has never read Cyrano de Bergerac.

None of this explains away the fundamental deception coded into Cluely.

I followed up on X with:

” ‘Cheat’ is a loaded word, but I also think it’s one we do understand. Google search is super-powered research, a digitization of encyclopedic knowledge at your fingertips. A calculator is a math wiz in your pocket, but one that was banned from class unless educators allowed it. They understood the potential for cheating. A browser tool that watches and listens and then produces an answer without the knowledge of the convo’s other participant is, many will agree, something different. BTW: Which LLM are you using?”

Lee has yet to respond, but perhaps that’s because he knows the answer. Google and Calculators are tools. Cluely is a tool hidden behind a lie: “This is me answering.”

It would be the same as secretly using Google or a calculator to answer an interviewer’s questions. There’s a fair chance they would notice your fingers frantically typing just off camera. Cluely just supercharges the subterfuge, but it doesn’t make it any less like cheating.

A brief hands on

I did, by the way, install Cluely on my MacBook Air to see how it works. It’s a powerful tool that overrides, with your permission, normal safeguards that stop third-party tools from watching the video and listening to the audio on your screen. It offers no alert to the person on the other side that they’re being watched by a massive AI brain.

It’s early days, and Cluely does not appear to be fully real-time. You have to click the AI button for it to work and provide answers. Even so, the potential is there, and it’s not necessarily a good one.

Lee’s efforts to normalize and redefine cheating won’t make it any less of a deception or any more acceptable. He got kicked out of school for it, and now he wants you to put your own reputation on the line. Some might do it, I know I won’t.

You might also like

Have questions? Need answers?

If you have any IT related issues, we have the solution for you. Whether you need long-term Mac and PC support or an urgent fix, don't hesitate and get in touch.

Contact us now!

Over 320 Satisfied Customers

I just wanted to say thank you for the visit today from SupportPlan. The engineer picked up many issues that we had outstanding and was professional and tireless! Really grateful for all his support and expertise today.

Beth, Operations Manager

SupportPlan has been a highly valued supplier to APR Communications, supporting our luxury PR agency from 1997 until 2018 when the company merged to become ANM.

We cannot recommend SupportPlan more highly.  Not only have SupportPlan provided an impeccable service; they have also been a true partner of the agency providing excellent counsel re our IT requirements and valuable cost-saving advice.

The team are very responsible and always go the extra mile in providing technical solutions in a user-friendly manner.

We wish Lance and the SupportPlan team our best and have been honoured to work with them.

Annabel McAvoy, Managing Partner, APR Communications LLP

All unforeseen problems were handled smoothly and calmly with the expertise of the engineers…[SupportPlan] sold me solutions and not technology.

Reginald Thompson, Conran Design Group Ltd

SupportPlan are fast, efficient, friendly and very knowledgeable. They have resolved any problems I have thrown their way and in quick time.  I would recommend them to any company.

Design Manager, Colliers International

I rely on SupportPlan. Even though I’m able to carry out certain tasks, it’s reassuring to know that SupportPlan is on the other end of the phone if I need them for back up.

Neil Hickford, Four IV Design

I work in a very busy marketing team. Knowing that SupportPlan are there to help us, in case of any problems has always been reassuring. They proved it one day when my Mac broke down as I was facing a tough deadline. Not only did SupportPlan swiftly replace the faulty computer, but their engineer also transferred all my files to the new Mac, enabling me to get back to work right away.

Claudia Mansaray, Marketing Communications Executive, Alzheimer's Society

I had the opportunity to work with your engineer via telephone today. I was so impressed with his helpfulness, knowledge and professionalism that I felt that I should send this email complement. Who ever hired him made the right decision. I will certainly be recommending your company to any other company I work with.

John McCrudden, MSc MCSE ACTC JNCIS-ER, "IT Infrastructure Specialist", Mitie Business Services

SupportPlan’s engineers have the knack for solving problems quickly by asking jargon-free questions that make a user feel like an IT expert.

Christine Holdforth, Manager, Corporate Publicity and Design Studio, Department of Education and Skills

SupportPlan is unusual in that the ‘top man’ is much more hands on with his clients than in other comparable organisations and is happy to step in when required. The engineers are responsive in a crisis and devote themselves to solving the problem efficiently.

Irena St John-Brooks, Managing Director, Pension Publications Ltd

SupportPlan are a rare breed in that they genuinely understand creative agencies and how we use IT in the business. They provide all our day-to-day IT support in a seamless and proactive way as well as advising us at a strategic level.

Financial Director, Salter Baxter

We were very impressed not only by the promptness of response but also by the consistency for the support…our Mac users were able to build up a strong working relationship with the regular team of experts from SupportPlan.

Richard Swann, IT Manager, Institute of Directors

I thoroughly recommend SupportPlan for whatever creative IT needs you may have…their expert knowledge is worth their weight in gold, let alone the service and range of services they back this up with. They are and always will be constant to my working life, as they have never let me down.

Neil Carter, Studio Manager, Penna Plc.

It’s reassuring to know that I have the breadth of skills of the SupportPlan team to back me up when I need them.

Gareth Perry, Group IT Manager, Eaglemoss

I have no hesitation recommending SupportPlan. They have maintained our computers for 12 years and they have ensured that any problems are resolved on the same day so we experienced as little down time during working hours. Their technicians are extremely knowledgeable and are always polite and helpful.

Accreditations


It’s not just our customers that recognise our hard work, we are accredited by Apple, Microsoft, Dell, HP, VMWare, Juniper, Kerio, Archiware P5, as well as many other manufacturers.

Our clients range from corporate giants, to hundreds of smaller businesses, many of whom rely on us to be their virtual IT department. They know we will never compromise on providing the right person for the right IT challenge and that’s why we’re the obvious first port of call when IT support is needed.

Bitwarden Certified Reseller
Google Workspace Essentials
IONOS Agency Partner
Dropbox Certified Administrator
Dropbox Certified Seller
Barracuda
Draytek
Mimecast Partners
Altaro Partners
Sophos Silver Partner
COMPTIA Network +
Cyber Essentials Certified – Security
silver-small-midmarket-cloud-solutions
Apple Certified Support Professional
Adobe Accredited Sales Specialist: Creative Cloud for teams
Adobe Certified Sales Professional: Volume Licensing
Adobe Certified Sales Professional: Acrobat XI
Adobe Certified Sales Professional: Creative Suite 6
Microsoft Certified Technology Specialist
CompTIA Certified
Dell PartnerDirect Registered
VMWare Certified Professional 4
Microsoft Small Business Specialist
Kerio Certified Partner
Apple Certified System Administrator
Apple Consultants Network
^Back to top